Final Word
By the Assistance of Allah , the Almighty , all the chains oftransmissions of the hadith were mentioned . The narrators , references , texts , and contents of the hadith were carefully and profoundly studied ; as a result , it found to be a fabricated hadith by the Family of Zubair , because narrators of the hadith are :
Abdullah b . Zubayr
Urwat b . Zubayr
Miysoar b . Makhramah , who was among the partisans andcompanions of Abdulllah that was killed in Ka`bah . He was among the Kharijians . . . Abdullah b . Abi Mulaykah , who was one of judgesappointed by Ibn Zubayr and his muezzin Zahri , who sat beside ' Urwat b . Zubayr and both of thenbackbited and swore Imam Ali , the Commander of the Faithful .
( peace be upon him ) . . . .
Shu`ayb b . Raashid , who was the narrator of Zahri's sayings .
Abu Yaman , who was Shu`ayb's narrator . These are the heads of fabricator s of this false hadith . Ofcourse , they were separately recognized and became clear thatall of them were the followers of their leader , i . e .
bdullah b . Zubayr , the one who is well - known to be a foe of Ahl al - Bay ( peace be upon them ) .
See his stories in Jamal Battle and other cases . He encircledBani Hashim in Abu Talib Defile to swear allegiance with him or to get ready for death . Among his other works is to exile Muhammad b . Hanafiyyahfrom Mecca andM edina and to exile Ibn ' Abbas to Ta'if and hisenmity with the Holy Prophet ( may God bless him and his progeny ) ,
In his short and well - known sayings , Imam Ali ( peace be upon him )